Search options Open Hide
  

  orReset
Original Flavor (Smoked)
$5.49
Developed in 1970 . Smooth, mild flavor makes this an excellent snacking cheese. No Added Hormones & Lactose Free ! Original...

Colby Smoked
Colby (Smoked)
$20.99
Cheese smoked to perfection with our "All Natural Hard Woods Blend Item Option: 3LB Wheel

Marble Smoked
Marble (Smoked)
$20.99
A creamy blend of Heini's White and Naturally Colored Colby Cheeses. Produced with no dry milk & no added hormones! Item Option: 3LB Wheel

Rose Petal Jelly
$8.99
Jelly of Red Roses Made in Germany Net Wt. .50g

Organic White Cheddar
$5.99
Item Option: 6oz Cracker Cut

Baby Swiss
$6.99
Heini's "Traditional Baby Swiss". Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being...

Lacey Baby Swiss
$5.49
"HEINI'S BEST SELLING CHEESE" This delicious cheese is produced using a time tested recipe, and our traditional cheese making methods! Weights are...

Baby Swiss Smoked
Baby Swiss (Smoked)
$20.99
This is our famous Baby Swiss Cheese smoked to perfection with an "All Natural Hard Woods Blend". Item Option: 3LB Wheel Wine Pairing: 2013...

54000
Sweet Hickory BBQ Sauce
$4.99
Mrs Miller's Homemade • All Natural Sweet Hickory BBQ Sauce Net Wt. 18 oz

54001
Southern Honey Mustard BBQ Sauce
$4.99
Mrs Miller's Homemade • All Natural Souther Honey Mustard BBQ Sauce Net Wt. 18 oz

52002
Sweet Mild Pepper Mustard
$4.99
Mrs Miller's Homemade Sweet Mild Pepper Mustard Net Wt. 9.5 oz

52003
Sweet Hot Pepper Mustard
$4.99
Mrs Miller's Homemade Sweet Hot Pepper Mustard Net Wt. 9.5 oz

19001
Apple Butter (sugarless)
$4.99
Heini's Sugarless Apple Butter Net Wt 8oz

Tomato Basil Pesto
$5.89
Heini's All-Naturall Tomato Basil Pesto Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Pasteurized Processed Cheese. Made with real basil. 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No...

White Cheddar Blueberry
$5.89
Heini's All-Naturall White Cheddar Blueberry Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Pasteurized Processed Cheese. Made with real cheddar. 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No...

Ingo's Original Wurstsauce
21004
Ingo's Original Wurstsauce
$8.99
This item is on back order!

00309
Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese Spread
$3.99
Heini's Cheese Spreads are loaded with flavor that you will love! This is a simple yet amazing solution for a quick party treat. You can dip your...

Pineapple Cream Cheese Spread
$3.99
Heini's Cheese Spreads are loaded with flavor that you will love! This is a simple yet amazing solution for a quick party treat. You can dip your...

00619
Cheddar Bacon
$5.89
Heini's Cheddar Bacon Pasteurized Processed Cheese Made with real Bacon. All-Natural 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No Artificial Growth Hormones. Net Wt....

169999
Apricot Jam
$4.99
Mrs. Miller's Homemade Apricot  Jam Net Wt. 8oz

Ben's Sweet & Hot BBQ Sauce
00005
Ben's Sweet & Hot BBQ Sauce
$7.99
Ben's Sweet & Hot BBQ Sauce This BBQ Sauce is sweet with a nice touch of heat.  Absolutely perfect when grilling ribs or chicken.  Cook a...

Black Currant Jelly
19006
Black Currant Jelly
$4.99
Mrs. Miller's Homemade Black Currant Jelly Net Wt. 8oz

Blueberry Preserves
Blueberry Preserves
$4.99
Mrs. Miller's Homemade Blueberry Preserves Net Wt. 8oz

00123
Milk Can Cheddar (Smoked)
$5.49
Heini's Amish Smoked Cheddar Cheese. Smoked with hickory wood chips. Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk, our old fashioned recipe makes this a favorite....

Save 24%
Jalapeno Pepper (chunk)
$5.89 $4.49
Heini's "Award Winning" Yogurt Cheese base loaded with spicy Jalapeno Peppers. Please note: This cheese is pre-cut into random weight.

Save 28%
Milk Can (Sliced)
$5.99 $4.29
Heini's All Natural Milk Can Cheddar Artificial Growth Hormones Free Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Microbial Coagulant, Cheese Cultures,...

Save 28%
Lacey Baby Swiss (Sliced)
$5.99 $4.29
Heini's All Natural Lacey Baby Swiss (slices) Semisoft Part-Skim Artificial Growth Hormones Free Ingredients: Pasteurized Part Skim Milk, Cheese...

00617
Ham N Cheese
$5.89
Heini's Ham N Cheese Made with Real Smoked Ham. All-Natural 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No Artificial Growth Hormones. Net Wt. Approx. 16oz (1lb)...

00618
Basil Pesto Cheese
$5.89
Heini's Basil Pesto Made with Real Parmesan. All-Natural. 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No Artificial Growth Hormones Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb) Ingredients:...

00616
Taco Cheese
$5.89
Heini's, Taco Cheese Made with Real Cilantro. All-Natural. 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No Artificial Growth Hormones Net Wt. Approx. 16oz (1lb)...

Save 42%
00910
Aged Harvati
$6.89 $3.99
Aged Harvati Yogurt (Butter Cheese) Available for limited time only. A Must try cheese! Please note: This cheese is pre-cut into random weight.

00702
Raw Milk Smoked Cheddar Cheese
$5.99
Heini's Raw Milk Cheese Statement Heini's Raw Milk Cheeses is produced without the processing aid known as pasteurization. Pasteurization is a process...

00616
Bombay Curry
$5.89
Heini's Bombay Curry Cheese Made with Real Curry All-Natural. 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No Artificial Growth Hormones Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb)...

00615
Smoked Ghost Pepper
$5.89
Heini's Smoked Ghost Pepper Made with Real Ghost Peppers All Natural. 100% Ohio Farm Milk. No Artificial Growth Hormones Net Wt. Approx 16oz (1lb)...

Insulated Packaging
$7.50
Insulated Carton W/ Ice Pack

Habanero Cheese
00125
Habanero
$5.99
Our best selling specialty, this cheese is hot enough to fly off the shelves and hot enough to satisfy even the fireiest cowboy. Real orange habanero...

Gift Basket #15
64014
Gift Basket #15
$99.99
Gift Basket #15 (4 ) 12oz Wheels of Cheese (2) 8oz Cracker Cuts of Cheese (1) Meat Choice (1) Trail Bologna...

Save 22% Wurstkuchl - 6.7oz
20008
Wurstkuchl
$8.99 $6.99
SPECIAL: BUY 3 OR MORE FOR $6.49 Each! Made in Germany Wurstkuchl Sweet and Hot Sweet Mustard www.wurstkuchlusa.com Sweet Mustard...

Lite Feta Cheese Cubes
65004
Feta Cheese Cubes
$7.99
FETA CHEESE CUBES www.ezrasdairy.com Delicate Feta cheese sliced in sea salt brine Artificial Growth Hormone Free, Gluten Free Store at...

Feta Cheese
65000
Feta Cheese Chunk
$7.99
FETA CHEESE CHUNK www.ezrasdairy.com Delicate Feta cheese in sea salt brine Artificial Growth Hormone Free, Gluten Free Store at...

YoChego "Sheep Milk"
00909
YoChego "Sheep Milk"
$13.49
Item Options: 8oz Cracker Cut Weights may vary due to being hand crafted. In the Heini's tradition of adding new and exciting...

O'Keeffe's Working Hands
63006
O'Keeffe's Working Hands
$14.49

O'Keeffe's Healthy Feet
63005
O'Keeffe's Healthy Feet
$14.49

Amish Origins Liquid Spray
63002
Amish Origins Liquid Spray
$13.99

Gift Basket
$25.00
test

Ben's Sweet & Hot Mustard - 8oz
00001
Ben's Sweet & Hot
$6.99
Ben's Sweet and Hot Mustard Net Wt. 8oz

Lovestruck Mix
52002
Lovestruck Mix
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

Mini Pink, White & Red Hearts
52003
Mini Pink, White & Red Hearts
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

Pink, Red & White Hearts
52005
Pink, Red & White Hearts
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

Pastel Yellow Sanding Sugar
60010
Pastel Yellow Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Pink Sanding Sugar
60011
Pink Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Purple Sanding Sugar
60012
Purple Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Red Sanding Sugar
60013
Red Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

White Sanding Sugars
60015
White Sanding Sugars
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Yellow Sanding Sugar
60016
Yellow Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Mixed Sanding Sugar
60004
Mixed Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Silver Sanding Sugar
60014
Silver Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Pastel Lavender Sanding Sugar
60008
Pastel Lavender Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Pastel Pink Sanding Sugar
60009
Pastel Pink Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Gold Sanding Sugar
60002
Gold Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Green Sanding Sugar
60003
Green Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Orange Sanding Sugar
60005
Orange Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Pastel Blue Sanding Sugar
60006
Pastel Blue Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Pastel Green Sanding Sugar
60007
Pastel Green Sanding Sugar
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .35lbs - .45lbs )

Coveretts, Bunnies, Chicks & Ducks
51001
Coveretts, Bunnies, Chicks & Ducks
$2.99

Easter Egg Shapes
51002
Easter Egg Shapes
$2.99

Mini Bunnies, Chicks, Ducks & Eggs
51003
Mini Bunnies, Chicks, Ducks & Eggs
$2.99

Pastel Egg Blend
51004
Pastel Egg Blend
$2.99

Silver Topperz
53008
Silver Topperz
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .20lbs - .30lbs )

56006
Holly Berry Mix
$1.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

56004
Christmas Mix Sanding Sugar
$2.49
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

56007
Holly Quins
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

56008
Jingle Mix Sanding Sugar
$2.49
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

56010
Noel Mix
$2.49
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

56013
Red & Green Tree Mix
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

Christmas Mix
56003
Christmas Mix
$1.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

Holiday Stars
56005
Holiday Stars
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

56001
Brown Gingerbread Men
$2.99
All weights are approximate and may vary. ( .25lbs - .35lbs )

27002
Cous-Cous with Chives & Saffron Soup Mix
$6.99

Lemon Angel Food Cake Mix
28004
Lemon Angel Food Cake Mix
$6.99

28005
Strawberry Angel Food Cake Mix
$6.99

28001
Carrot Cake Mix
$4.99

28003
Gingerbread Cake Mix
$4.99

29001
Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
$4.99

Blueberry Muffin Mix
32000
Blueberry Muffin Mix
$3.99

Coconut Macaroon Cookie Mix
29002
Coconut Macaroon Cookie Mix
$6.99

Snicker Doodle Cookie Mix
29003
Snicker Doodle Cookie Mix
$4.99

Brownie Mix
29000
Brownie Mix
$4.99

Corn Muffin Mix
32001
Corn Muffin Mix
$3.99

Honey Bran Muffin Mix
32002
Honey Bran Muffin Mix
$3.99

Chocolate Angel Food Cake Mix
28002
Chocolate Angel Food Cake Mix
$6.99

Creamy Chicken Noodle Soup Mix
27004
Creamy Chicken Noodle Soup Mix
$7.99

White Cheddar Asparagus Soup Mix
27008
White Cheddar Asparagus Soup Mix
$9.99

Holiday Soup Mix
27007
Holiday Soup Mix
$4.99

Hearty Soup Mix
27006
Hearty Soup Mix
$4.99

Cheddar Broccoli & Rice Soup Mix
27000
Cheddar Broccoli & Rice Soup Mix
$7.99
    Cancel