Search options Open Hide
  

  orReset
Save 50%
Plum Butter
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Plum Butter Net Wt. 9.5oz (269g) *while supplies last

Save 50% blueberry
Blueberry Preserve
$5.99 $2.99
Amishh Valley Farms Blueberry Preserve Net WT. 15.5oz (439) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Pumpkin Butter
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Pumpkin Butter Net Wt. 9.5oz (269g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Boysenberry
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Boysenberry Jam Net Wt. 10.5oz (297) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Red Pepper Jelly
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Red Pepper Jelly Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Cherry Butter
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Cherry Butter Net Wt. 10oz (283g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Red Purple Plum
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Red Purple plum Jelly Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Elderberry
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Elderberry Jelly Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Red Raspberry Preserve
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Red Raspberry Preserve Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Fig Preserve
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Fig Preserve Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Seedless Black Raspberry Preserve
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Seedless Black Raspberry Preserve Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Hot Chow Chow
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Hot Chow Chow Net Wt. 8oz (237g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Strawberry Preserve
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Strawberry Preserve Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Orange Marmalade
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Orange Marmalade Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Strawberry-Rhubarb Preserve
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Strawberry-Rhubarb Preserve Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Orange Pineapple-Cherry Marmalade
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Orange Pineapple-Cherry Marmalade Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Artichoke
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Artichoke Relish Net Wt. 8oz (236ml) *while supplies last

Save 50% Jelly
Apple Cinnamon
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Apple Cinnamon Jelly Net Wt 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Peach Preserve
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Peach Preserve Net Wt. 10.5oz (297g) *while supplies last

Save 50%
Green Tomato
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Green Tomato Relish Net Wt 8oz (236ml) *while supplies last

Save 50% Apricot Butter
Apricot Butter
$4.99 $2.49
Amish Valley Farms Apricot Butter Net wt. 9.0oz (255g) *while supplies last

Easter Basket
$35.99
Happy Easter This wonderful Easter Basket includes: 1 Heini's Raw Milk cracker cut 1 Heini's Marble cracker cut 1 Heini's Colonial Cheddar cracker cut 1...

Swissters Alpine Cheese
Swissters Alpine Cheese
$5.49
Heini's Swissters Alpine Cheese Creamy Cheese | Mild in flavor Artificial Growth | Hormone Free

Gouda
Everyday Gouda
$5.49
Heini's Everyday Gouda Semi-Soft, smooth creamy texture with a nutty flavor. 100% All-Natural Farm Milk | Artificial Hormone Free Try it on your...

Cashew Snappers (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free cashew Snappers

Coconut Dip (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free Coconut Dip Weight: 1LB

Vanilla Caramel (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free Vanilla Caramel Weight: 1LB

Pecan Snappers (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free Pecan Snappers Weight: 1LB

Coconut Crunch
$5.99
Coconut Crunch Weight: Approximately 1LB

Peanut Dip (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free Chocolate Peanut Dip Weight: 1LB

Fruit Slices
$2.99
Fruit Slices Weight: Approximately 1LB

Maple Nut
Maple Nut
$4.99
Chocolate Maple Nut Goodies

Sugar Free
Peanut Butter Meltaway (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Meltaway Weight: 1LB

Sour Neon Worm
$3.99
Sour Neon Worm Weight: Approximately 1LB

Raisin Dip (Sugar Free)
$13.99
Sugar Free Chocolate Raisin Dip

Gift Basket #10
64001
Gift Basket #10
$59.99
Gift Basket #10 ( 4) 12oz Wheels of Cheese Honey Roasted Peanuts Caramel Popcorn Homemade Chocolates...

Gift Basket #9
64008
Gift Basket #09
$51.99
Gift Basket #9 (2 ) 12oz Wheels of Cheese Trail Bologna Ben's Sweet & Hot Mustard Box of Crackers...

Gift Basket #6
64005
Gift Basket #06
$47.99
Gift Basket #6 (3 ) 12oz Wheels of Cheese (1) 12oz Beef Stick (3) 1.5oz Mustards or Jellies Homemade Chocolates...

Gift Basket #5
64004
Gift Basket #05
$47.99
Gift Basket #5 ( 4) 12oz Wheels of Cheese Wooden Crate Included Shipping Included Include a personalized...

Buckeyes
$6.99
Milk Chocolate Buckeyes Weight: approximately 1LB

Buckeyes
$6.99
Dark Chocolate Buckeyes Weight: approximately 1LB

Dark Chocolate Caramel (w/sea-salt)
$12.99
Dark Chocolate Cameral with Sea-Salt Weight: 1LB

taffy
Taffy
$3.99
Asssorted Saltwater Taffy Weight:1LB

Lemon Verbena Syrup
Lemon Verbena Syrup
$9.99
Lemon Verbena Syrup Net Wt. 8 FL OZ Ingredients: Natural Evaporated Cane Juice, Water, Lemon Verbena Infusion, Lemon Slice, Citric Acid.

One Pint
Maple Syrup (16oz)
$15.99
Pure Maple Syrup Holmes County Ohio Net Wt. 16FL oz

Salted Caramel Syrup
Salted Caramel Syrup
$9.99
Salted Caramel Syrup Net Wt. 8 FL OZ Ingredients: Natural Evaporated Cane Sugar, Water, Maple Syrup, Organic Caramel Flavoring, (Water, Organic Gum...

One Quart
Maple Syrup (32oz)
$22.99
Pure Maple Syrup Holmes County Ohio Net Wt. 32 FL oz

Butter Pecan Syrup
Butter Pecan Syrup
$9.99
Butter Pecan Syrup NetWt 8 FL OZ Ingredients: Evaporated Cane Juice Crystals, Water, Pure Maple Syrup, Natural Butter Flavor, Pecan Pieces, Citrid Acid
    Cancel