Amish Farm Milk Cheese

$6.99
Heini's "Traditional Baby Swiss". Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being...

$5.49
Loads of delicious Onion in a creamy Natural Cheese base. A favorite of Heini's customers for over fifty years! Weights are approximate and can...

$5.49
Heini's Butter Cheese. Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....

$5.49
The flavor of fresh baked Rye Bread blended into a creamy mild cheese base. Great snacking cheese! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...

$5.49
People call this " Country Gold ". This traditional recipe Colby Cheese will have you dreaming about your childhood.  Mild, creamy and...

$5.49
Heini's very own "Colonial" style cheddar. Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....

$5.99
We cannot think of many combinations more perfect than dill and our supple Jack cheese. The creamy mild Jack has a slight buttery aroma and is given a...
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk, our old fashioned recipe makes this a favorite. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....

$5.99
Fennel has a fresh and delicious taste and scent, often used in Mediterranean dishes. With our creamy Monterey Jack, the fennel combines to realize a...
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Heini's creamy Marble Cheese loaded with plenty of chopped Jalapeno Peppers for a delicious, spicy treat! Weights are approximate and can vary, due...
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Our best selling specialty, this cheese is hot enough to fly off the shelves and hot enough to satisfy even the fireiest cowboy. Real orange habanero...
+
Add to wish list

$6.99
If you are a true horseradish lover, this cheese is for you. The potent bite of real horseradish root, from Lennon, Michigan, is soothed by the pairing...
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Zesty Jalapeno Peppers blended into Heini's creamy White Colby base for just the right amount of zip! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...

$5.49
"HEINI'S BEST SELLING CHEESE" This delicious cheese is produced using a time tested recipe, and our traditional cheese making methods! Weights...

$5.49
A creamy blend of Heini's White and Naturally Colored Colby Cheeses.  Produced with no dry milk & no added hormones! Weights are...

$5.49
Authentic, Milled Cheddar produced Naturally with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.  ...

$5.49
"Tuscan Style" Olive & Pimento Diced green Olives and flavorful pimento bits blended into a creamy, mild cheese. Artificial Growth Hormone...
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Heini's traditional "Milled Cheddar" aged to perfection! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item...

$5.49
Heini's traditional "Milled Cheddar" aged to perfection! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item...

$8.99
Amish Farm Milk "Old World Swiss" Created in Holmes County, Ohio. Hand cut from 200lb blocks. Contains No Added Hormones! Weights are...
+
Add to wish list

$8.99
If you love Mushrooms, this cheese will tantalize your taste buds. We use black truffle peelings and white truffle oil to give this cheese its rich flavor....
+
Add to wish list