Cheese & Meat Selections

$5.49
Our smooth Colby base loaded with bits of delicious Bacon flavor! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted. Items...

$5.49
Loads of delicious Onion in a creamy Natural Cheese base. A favorite of Heini's customers for over fifty years! Weights are approximate and can vary,...

$20.99
Loads of delicious onions in a natural creamy cheese base. Smoked to perfection with our "All Natural Hard Woods Belnd". Item Option: 3LB Wheel
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Heini's Butter Cheese. Some people say that it doesn't get any better than this. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....

$5.49
The flavor of fresh baked Rye Bread blended into a creamy mild cheese base. Great snacking cheese! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...

$5.49
People call this " Country Gold ". This traditional recipe Colby Cheese will have you dreaming about your childhood. Mild, creamy and delicious!...

$5.49
Heini's very own "Colonial" style cheddar. Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....

$20.99
Our Colonial Cheddar cheese smoked to satisfy. Smoked with our "All Natural Hard Woods Blend" Item Option: 3LB Wheel
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Produced with 100% Amish Farm Milk, our old fashioned recipe makes this a favorite. Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted....

$20.99
Our "Famous Farmers" cheese smoked to perfection with our "All Natural Hard Woods Blend" Item Option: 3LB Wheel
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Heini's creamy Marble Cheese loaded with plenty of chopped Jalapeno Peppers for a delicious, spicy treat! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...
+
Add to wish list

$11.49
1LB of Heini's All Natural Garlic Cheese Curds! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to being hand-crafted.   Item Options:...
+
Add to wish list


$59.95
+
Add to wish list

$58.95
+
Add to wish list

$60.95
+
Add to wish list

$67.95
+
Add to wish list

$68.95
+
Add to wish list

$95.95
+
Add to wish list

$95.95
+
Add to wish list

$51.95
+
Add to wish list

$5.99
Our best selling specialty, this cheese is hot enough to fly off the shelves and hot enough to satisfy even the fireiest cowboy. Real orange habanero...
+
Add to wish list

$5.49
Zesty Jalapeno Peppers blended into Heini's creamy White Colby base for just the right amount of zip! Weights are approximate and can vary, due to...

$7.50
Insulated Carton W/ Ice Pack
+
Add to wish list